First, the pundits are kidding themselves if they honestly think that the 2008 presidential election will be a two-way race between Hillary Clinton and John McCain. That matchup is nothing but idle chatter. That said, I think McCain has a far better shot of getting the GOP nomination than Hillary does of getting the Democratic nomination. Hillary has some very serious negatives that will stymie her, including the fact that she cannot give an explanation of her presidential aspirations that will sound acceptable to Iowa, New Hampshire, and Nevada voters.
Since at least 2000, probably earlier, it’s been known that she harbors the ambition. Running for an open seat in a blue state was merely a platform from which she would explore her options. Ambition is a good thing, certainly not anything shameful. But for a solid six years, her ambitions have been obvious, overt, and highly calculated — and the source of the ambition is absolutely nothing but her own desire. I don’t question her patriotism, but she isn’t considering a presidential run because of it. She’s considering a run purely because of her own ego, and it’s been evident for over half a decade. I don’t think she’ll ever shake that.
McCain, however, is a more likely prospect. Let’s examine the ramifications of that.
The Republican Party has been in a civil war since the election. The “moderate” wing is basically nonexistent now, and the conservatives are at each other’s throats. The PNAC set, led by Cheney, Rumsfeld, & Co., appears to have been sidelined in favor of the Reagan/Bush1 Iran-Contra characters, symbolized by Robert Gates. The grassroots have been drawing blood wherever they go, with the anti-immigration conservatives, the fundamentalists, and the diehard neoconservative supporters taking breaks from the bloodbath only to fire volleys indiscriminately at George Bush.
The charge they typically level is that the administration and the outgoing Congress have sold out true conservatism, and that they must retake their party. Yes, that’s right — Americans threw the bums out because they were too liberal, at least according to the deranged and delusional right-wing blogosphere.
They’re angry.
They’re feeling betrayed.
And they are the Republican base.
John McCain is a conservative. Unabashedly. He has some persistent but dwindling crossover appeal because of his campaign finance reform bill (which, in one of life’s wonderful ironies, he himself later violated) and his carefully constructed media image as a maverick. The man is nothing of the sort, but it would seem that the Republican base doesn’t necessarily get that.
No, they HATE him with a burning passion. He is definitely too liberal for them. In fact, almost all of the prospective Republicans are too liberal for the base, or have some other problem with their base.
McCain and Giuliani are perceived as liberal. The only one who could arguably claim to be a social moderate is Giuliani, but they both have that perception.
Outgoing Governor Mitt Romney (R-MA) is a Mormon and also has a record of some social liberalism. More than that, though, he’s an abject failure that the state is glad to be rid of.
Condoleezza Rice is closely associated with the Bush administration and is therefore DOA. She is also a black woman, and there’s no way that all of the factions of right-wingers can coalesce around her.
I used to give Bill Frist a lot more credibility as a candidate. However, since then, he has been shown to be incompetent, quite frankly. And by retiring, forced the GOP to pour money to defend that seat instead of sending it north to Virginia. He’s also in favor of stem cell research, an unforgivable sin among the fundamentalist set.
Speaking of Virginia, George Allen, formerly a star, has fallen from grace with his Senate loss. (More on soon-to-be Ex-Senator Macaca in a bit.)
Newt Gingrich is on his third marriage and resigned from his position in disgrace. He was exposed as a hypocrite in the 1990s for attacking Bill Clinton for the same behavior that he himself committed, and worst of all, he served his first wife the divorce papers while she was on a hospital bed after receiving cancer treatments.
That leaves the two dark horse candidates, Senator Sam Brownback (KS) and Governor Mike Huckabee (AR). Both are conservative enough for the base, but they are virtual unknowns. I suspect this will change and one of them will break out as the conservative of choice for the disgruntled right-wingers.
However, McCain could still win the nomination. I predict it will be a nasty, brutal contest between him and one of the right-wing dark horses.
If Brownback or Huckabee gets it, it opens up the possibility of an absolute landslide for the Democrat. I’m talking 300+ electoral votes. Look for Ohio, Iowa, New Mexico, and possibly Missouri and Virginia to flip from their 2004 recorded results. Why Virginia? Well, it has elected two Democratic governors in a row, and now a U.S. Senator. The trend is undeniable. And there’s chatter that popular Republican incumbent John Warner will retire in 2008 and Macaca Man will attempt to weasel his way back into the Senate by running for this seat… against even more popular former governor Mark Warner. With a highly regarded former governor possibly on the ballot, and a star-powered freshman Senator (Webb) making the rounds, Virginia is ripe to turn blue.
IF the Democratic Party nominates someone who can take advantage of the situation, that is.
If McCain gets it, look for the disaffected right-wing base to go third party. Yes, you heard that right. I think they are in deadly earnest. The rage I have seen on right-wing blogs and forums is unbelievable, and it’s not just blogs. George Bush has abysmal approval ratings around the country, including parts of the conservative South, but in such conservative strongholds, the disapproval is from conservatives who feel that Bush has been a bad conservative. They haven’t repudiated their ideology, just this worthless excuse for a president, and they’d be receptive to a “new” conservative. Any third-party candidate that seized upon this would do well. With a right-wing third party siphoning off perhaps 20% of the vote, I must concede that McCain would be more likely to pick up independent voters. They would see him as the “middle” in such a race, although there wouldn’t be much practical difference between him and the challenger from the Right.
2008 is shaping up to be an exciting race. This kind of thing doesn’t happen that often, and when it does, it’s worth an extra bag of popcorn.
If you’re a casual observer, that is, with no stake in it. Which I am highly unlikely to be. So if my prediction turns out right, you can have my popcorn. Do enjoy it.
